Home

  • BOOKS 

    Finding the Indians Missing From Sanskritised Historical Texts

    article_Author
    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd

    Nov 8 2026

    All the Sanskrit books deal only with the lives of Brahmins and Kshatriyas, and both these castes belong to one Aryan race. The Indians who actually built the Harappan civilisation do not exist in them.

    finding the indians missing from sanskritised historical texts

    Harappa returns with a baby buffalo, 2026, Harappa: God’s City of Civilization, chapter 1 (left); Radha and Krishna, 1901, Raja Ravi Varma (right), image credit: Raja Ravi Varma Heritage Foundation

    Ancient Indian peoples’ race and caste character is still troubled terrain. Once some clarity comes with careful study of their early racial, civilisational, and cultural character, modern Indian society’s roots and their connection to Shudra/Dalit/Adivasi ancient history can be understood.

    Understanding the Harappan civilisation builders is the key to re-evaluating Indian racial roots. Reading the Sanskrit texts written after the settlement of Aryan migrants, starting with Rigveda, does not give us any clues to the nature of ancient Indian society. All the Sanskrit books deal only with the lives of Brahmins and Kshatriyas, and both these castes belong to one Aryan race. Neither food producers nor builders of the animal economy nor technological innovators exist in those books. No trace of skin colours or other racial characteristics comparable to those of present day Shudras, Dalits, or Adivasis can be found in those books. Even the most popular Ramayana, the Mahabharata, reflects only Brahmin and Kshatriya life, culture, and colour. Only a few, e.g., Srirama and Srikrishna, are even shown as mixed race. This we can see in paintings or idol images of Rama and Krishna, though in very modern Indian dress.

    Rakshas/Vanaras, another category of characters in those books, also do not engage in food production, animal husbandry, or tool-making. Thus, no ancient Sanskrit books reflect the real racial and caste origins of the people who founded Indian civilisation, or how the later imposition of the caste system stunted economic and cultural development in India.

    Painted or illustrated ancient humans

    The most prominent mythological images of ancient men and women are the paintings and illustrations of Raja Ravi Varma, a South Indian Kshatriya, who mapped his contemporary ruling family images, dress codes, colour, and body type according to his understanding of the Kshatriya and Brahmin families of his time. He seems to have relied on textual descriptions in depicting the subjects of his paintings. Consequently, his images of supposedly ancient mythological figures, both male and female, do not manifest any ancientness. They instead appear fashionably modern. Their clothing, ornaments and houses do not represent ancient Indian economic, civilisational and cultural environments at all. His people of Krita Yuga or Treta Yuga look like modern Kshatriyas or Brahmins – mostly of North India.

    Similar characteristics are found in Indian temple idols and cinematic characters. We find no ancientness in them. For example, the Ramayana is said to date back to Krita Yuga and the Mahabharata to Dwapara Yuga, but we cannot locate them in any time frame of ancient civilization. If we compare their dress, body and facial images to those of our freedom fighters, the freedom fighters look more like ancient people than Ramayana and Mahabharata figures.

    The texts and associated images are inconsistent with what we know of material production in ancient times. The people of Krita Yuga or Dwapara Yuga had not developed technologies for producing the clothes, ornaments, shoes, chappals, or other fashionable commodities depicted in Varma’s images.

    In the societies portrayed in the Ramayana andMahabharata, was there tillage agriculture using buffalo-bulls? Was there irrigation? Were there crop-harvesting systems? Was there social interaction among productive castes? Were consumer tastes of Brahmins and Kshatriyas in those times similar to modern tastes? No to all. Both the written word and painted or illustrated images should reflect the production systems of the era they purport to represent. But there’s ample evidence that Ramayana and Mahabharata were written during early modern times and are only claimed to be ancient. Likewise, the “ancient” people in Varma’s paintings are creatures of the modern existence depicted in those texts.

    Sanskrit books and history

    Real human history does not come into play in the Sanskrit texts, as they were mostly written by Brahmins who had no footing in the production process. Their feet sat instead under the folded legs of Rishis, and their hands did no work; they were used only for worshipping the Kshatriya rulers as Gods and their women as Goddesses. Their roles are imaginary, highly exaggerated, and situated in no known time frame. Varma’s paintings also reflect none of the socio-economic conditions of ancient Indian civilization that developed with several new innovations of technologies and methods of production.

    Priti Gulati Cox’s illustration of Harappans

    Maisamma builds a reservoir, 2026,  Harappa: God’s City of Civilization, chapter 3 (left); Saraswati, 1890, Raja Ravi Varma (right), image credit: Raja Ravi Varma Heritage Foundation

    Once I completed the first draft of Harappa: God’s City of Civilisation, my longtime friend and editor of Countercurrents, Binu Mathew, sent the manuscript to Priti Gulati Cox (born and brought up in India), who lives in the US along with her husband Stan Cox. She liked the scheme of the novel and eagerly agreed to illustrate the story’s characters, events, and locations. Having no idea how she would portray ancient Indian people, I waited eagerly to see her first sketches.

    As she later wrote in our book’s Afterword, she was “thrilled to illustrate Harappa: God’s City of Civilization” She became the first person to give physical shape to India’s original civilisation builders. Present-day Adivasi/Dalit/Shudras will see themselves in her portrayals of their ancient ancestors. Her figures broadly resemble our Tribals of central India, including the Gonds, Koyas, Bills, Santhals and many others.

    Priti’s magnificent work is based on her deep study of research by archeologists, historians, and anthropologists that has revealed much about the Harappan people and their civilization, built environment, animal economy, food production, water management and other technological accomplishments. However, she did not romanticise the ancient lifestyle of the main character Harappa’s family or the many others who built the big village of Jambhu Dwipa and developed it into the first civilised city of the ancient world, Harappa.

    Race and caste

    Vigraharadhi presents Harappa with a sculpture of him, Harappa: God’s City of Civilization, chapter 6 (left); Coronation of Rama, 1905, Raja Ravi Varma (right), image credit: Google Arts and Culture

    Even in India, the caste question is crucially connected to the race question. As I was writing the novel, I focused on several main themes: how the villagers domesticated animals; how in their economic development, they built a city of such magnitude, featuring kiln-fired bricks, advanced wood craft, and large water bodies and distribution systems; and how their productive, cooperative, egalitarian social structure evolved.

    I knew that the people who built the Harappan civilisation were a mixture of racial backgrounds and had no caste system. However, that was not the subject of my novel. My focus was on their everyday life. Priti’s illustrations gave life to my words, depicting the evolution of a people’s civilisation and culture.

    When I received proofs of the book with Priti’s illustrations incorporated throughout, I noticed that she rendered them in shades of graphite-gray in the early chapters, then gradually added bits of color here and there in the middle chapters, before moving to vivid full-color toward the end. I asked her about the purpose of her evolving color scheme. She said that throughout the book the illustrations were rendered with no sharp detail or outlines, as if they were people, animals, and scenes visible only through deep mists of time. The first four chapters, she said, depicted the people of the village that would become Harappa as they had lived for millennia, as an integral part of the natural world. Given that no traces of early societies like that remain, she said, she depicted it in monochrome.

    Starting with Chapter 3, in which the villagers begin working with nature in ways that improve the life of the village, she said, she began adding color in natural tones to details in some of the scenes: a peacock by a water tank, terra-cotta bangles on the arms of dancers at the winter solstice, copper being smelted. In Chapter 5, she began introducing scenes entirely in color, but she stuck to strictly earth tones: clothing, some adorned with vegetable dye, buildings constructed with red-clay bricks, a wooden boat.

    She pointed out that Chapter 9, in which a small team of itinerant Aryans enter the story, begins with a landscape scene in subdued colors, save for one ominous sight: a stretch of saffron-colored sky on the horizon. In her illustrations for the final two chapters, Priti portrayed the pale-skinned bodies of the Aryans against a full palette of intense Holi colours. She portrayed the book’s final image, featuring thumbnails of Harappa’s indigenous technologies (arranged on the branches of a tree that is depicted among archeological finds in Harappa) as having been painted on white paper, the edges of which are being consumed by bright saffron-orange flames. And the tip of the tree has caught fire as well.

    Production and painting       

    Harappa & Maisamma as elders, Harappa: God’s City of Civilization, chapter 8 (left); Shri Sheshanarayana, 1886, Raja Ravi Varma (right), image credit: Google Arts & Culture

    Any people as a race or tribe as a social group survives by growing crops from the earth, while exploiting naturally available food resources: land, animals, fish, wild fruits and tubers, etc. But books written by Brahmins in Sanskrit, from Rigveda to Manudharma and after, erased the very existence of any ethnic groups, castes, and communities that were involved in food production and food gathering. This, I realised when I was doing extensive reading of literature on the Harappan civilisation which thrived well before the arrival of Aryans. The Brahmins of modern India, the main representatives of the Aryan race, composed the Vedas almost 1,500 years after the heyday of Harappa, the world’s first great civilisation.

    The Brahmins deliberately avoided including the role of productive communities in their ancient texts. They, along with the Kshatriya kings, played a key role in denying education in their real history. They erased the history of a civilisation that existed long before the Aryans migrated into the Subcontinent and replaced it with a history that existed only in their own minds.

    Tony Joseph’s theory of migration

    Harappan “tree of life” up in flames, Harappa: God’s City of Civilization, chapter 10 (left); Krishna’s Embassy to Duryodhana, 1905, Raja Ravi Varma (right), image credit: Google Arts & Culture

    As Tony Joseph, a great historian and writer, proved in his book Early Indians, the Harappa civilisation was built by people descended from two groups of ancestors: early migrants from Africa and a population of farmers who had migrated from the area that’s now western Iran. The Africans were dark skinned whereas those from West Asia were colored people. The intermixing of these two waves of migrants produced the Harappans, who later seem to have been designated Shudras.

    The light-skinned Aryans, who migrated into the northern Subcontinent from the steppes of Central Asia met and, over time, mingled with dark-skinned people of Harappa, producing a racially diverse population upon which, centuries later, the Brahmins would impose an unjust caste system. Meanwhile, immigrants from the region of Mongolia settled in far-eastern India, what we now call the Northeast, adding another group to the race-caste social structure.

    Priti’s illustrations capture the first migrant races that settled in the Sindhu River region and built the Harappan economy, civilisation and culture, generation after generation. They finally built the greatest earliest urban civilisation in India much before the Aryan arrived here. Her colours show that they resemble the Dravidian masses of India, South and North. She also showed the newly arrived Aryans: a white-skinned, black-haired, and blue-eyed folk, with their horses, cows, bulls, and iron weapons.

    Conclusion

    Descendants of the Harappans – present-day Shudras, Dalis, and Adivasis – were forbidden by the later migrant Aryans to write books about their ancient life. This novel is the first one to put that ancient story in fictional form, but based on what we have learned from scholarship in archeology, history, and genetics about the Harappan people, their civilisation and culture. They are the Indians who do not exist in the Sanskrit books written by ancient and medieval Brahmins. And today’s ruling caste-class Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh/Bharatiya Janata Party forces continue to compel Shudra/Dalit/Adivasi students to read ancient Sanskrit books – and accept them as actual history – in schools and colleges.

    Harappa: God’s City of Civilization can provide students an opportunity to read about and see how the first Indians – their ancestors – looked and worked in a far more ancient India than the Sanskrit books describe.

    Cox has portrayed Harappans, the actual ancestors of the Shudra/Dalit/Adivasi masses, not the fanciful characters in Ramayana and Mahabharatafamously painted by Raja Ravi Varma. He showed them in his own class, caste, race mirror, whereas Priti has shown the Harappans as they really were.

    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd is a political theorist, social activist and author. His latest book is The Shudra Rebellion.

    https://m.thewire.in/article/books/finding-the-indians-missing-from-sanskritised-historical-texts

  • HARAPPA God’s City of Civilisation

    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd

    Priti Gulati Cox

    An imaginative, beautifully illustrated, and ethically motivated fiction about what life in ancient times may have been like. Written by a leading social justice activist and intellectual tied to Dalit-Bahujan politics, the story frames the Indus civilization as the work of pastoralists and producing groups. Its descriptions of how innovations came about, by accident or cleverness, and then spread from village to village are a persuasive way of imagining how societies, if not civilization, developed. Certainly there was time—many thousands of years in the Indus Valley and surrounding areas—for new ideas and practices to germinate, spread, and take root.

    The focus on animals, and on the close interactions that would have developed between them and humans, is a welcome change from the usual emphasis on agriculture and creates rich opportunities for storytelling.

    The author eschews the usual social categories like caste and religion, which is refreshing, especially since we know so little about what people believed so long ago, let alone what they called their religion. That said, traditional male and female roles are largely maintained, and one is struck by how harshly young animals are taken from their mothers; possibly this was how animal husbandry developed, or not. One might also question the use of names like Harappa and Mohenjo for characters. They do evoke something for us today, though I’m not sure it works. The story also ends somewhat abruptly, something the narrative frame acknowledges explicitly when it resolves the battle between the indigenous inhabitants and the “aliens” (presumably Aryans), as the author calls them.

    The Epilogue summarizes the story’s hopeful motivation: “As the Western world claims that they are the descendants of Abraham, we are the descendants of Harappa and Maisamma. We are descendants of both father and mother, not just father alone. Many Kathammas [the storyteller] will write, not just tell stories of our ancestors of this land and its civilisation and culture. That will again make India a nation that will lead the world in so many spheres, as the city civilisation and culture of Harappa did in ancient times.”

    The illustrations are excellent and feel authentic to the material culture as we know or suspect it from the limited evidence we have today. As a visionary story to expand children’s ideas of how early society may have come together around animals and the earth, Harappa: God’s City of Civilisation is a compelling work.

    Buy

    Amazon India

    Unbound Script

    OCLC

    1618066013

    Fiction

  • Many hands make history

    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd’s latest book, which can also be read as an intellectual biography of his Kuruma community, demands an overhaul of how we see and measure knowledge, language, gender, and human dignity.

    NIKHIL SANJAY-REKHA ADSULE

    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd at his residence in Hyderabad on October 1, 2017.

    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd at his residence in Hyderabad on October 1, 2017. | Photo Credit: G. Ramakrishna

    Today, public debates over caste are centred on the caste census and quota sub-classification. This binary discourse misses an important contradiction. Agrarian working classes, classified as Shudras in the Rigvedic varna system, form a formidable voting bloc for every political party across India. Yet the intellectual history and the philosophy of these labouring communities remain ignored. Thinking and writing in India have historically been guarded property, “reserved” for those with the inter- and intragenerational luxury of “free time” and “elite schooling”. Professor Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd’s recent autobiography, A Shudra Life, serves as an alternative political history that challenges the gatekeeping of both the “conservative” Right and the “traditional” Marxist Left. Ilaiah’s autobiography can also be read as an intellectual biography of his Kuruma community. He demands a complete overhaul of how we “see” and “measure” knowledge, language, gender, and human dignity.

    Ilaiah’s social consciousness, his advocacy for women’s agency, and the bedrock of his anti-caste feminist thinking and doing were shaped by the women in his life, especially his grandmother and his mother, Kancha Kattamma. In a habitus where his father was absent for long stretches of time grazing sheep, his mother was the matriarch and leader of their Kuruma community. Ilaiah points to the subaltern origins of his name, which derives from Iloni Mallanna, a legendary shepherd chieftain of the Deccan plateau who was revered as a local deity. This naming grounds his identity in local geography and history rather than in Brahmanical scriptures. He recounts incidents in which Kattamma bravely resisted extortion by local forest guards and dominant-caste authorities. This resistance came at a cost, though: she was brutally assaulted in a confrontation with a feudal landlord’s family. Ilaiah thus strips away any romantic notions of rural harmony and the rhetoric of village republics, neither of which he encountered as a young man.

    A Shudra Life reminds us that the right to think, write, and create theory is a basic human entitlement that belongs to every human being, irrespective of birth-imposed identities.

    A Shudra Life reminds us that the right to think, write, and create theory is a basic human entitlement that belongs to every human being, irrespective of birth-imposed identities. | Photo Credit: By special arrangement

    A Shudra Life

    By Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd

    SouthSide Books
    Pages: 200
    Price: Rs.400

    Hailing as he did from a Shudra shepherd community, Ilaiah entered school only after overcoming considerable opposition within the community, which stemmed from its limited awareness of formal education. His family, too, dreaded the idea, harbouring a multigenerational belief that Goddess Saraswati would kill Shudra children if they dared to read and write. Within the village’s caste hierarchy, literacy was seen as a spiritual weapon reserved strictly for elite castes. Today, as a critique of the education system, Ilaiah distinguishes between the “creative wealth” produced by manual labourers and the “non-productive lifestyle” of spiritual elites. He theorises that animal herding, soil management, and artisanal work constitute political philosophy. Echoing Brecht, he argues that it is the labouring hands of the Shudra and working collectives that have created human civilisation.

    Buffalo versus cow nationalism

    Ilaiah, who has mooted the study of the “sciences of production”, contrasts the state-sanctioned, sacred status of the “white cow” with the deliberate demonisation and neglect of the “black buffalo”. Despite being the chief driver of India’s dairy economy and the foundational capital of Shudra and OBC households, the buffalo has been marginalised in sacred literature and classical aesthetics. Ilaiah attributes this to the animal’s colour and its close association with Dravidian working-class labour. He also argues that a mythological figure such as Krishna, whom he reads as an indigenous, non-Aryan cattle herder and tribal deity of the Yadava clan, was co-opted and recast by elites as a warrior hero and an agent of orthodox ethics, thereby robbing pastoral communities of their organic spiritual icon.

    Ilaiah exposes a contradiction in the postcolonial Indian state: the ruling classes publicly praised regional languages for the common people while quietly maintaining a monopoly on English. However, he also rejects the romantic view that regional languages are naturally pure or democratic, showing them to be social structures packed with historical hierarchies and marked by everyday insults. When the young Ilaiah saw an English-speaking Dalit District Collector whom the Reddy landlords feared, he concluded that “English” was the secret gateway to power and a means of annihilating the caste system. It was English that allowed a shepherd boy to communicate directly with global anti-colonial frameworks. This aligns with Frantz Fanon’s view of language in his brilliant work Black Skin, White Masks.

    Ilaiah’s critique of caste also extends to the dinner table. He points to the patriarchy and hierarchies embedded in food cultures across communities. He shows how a dominant nationalism built on “pure vegetarianism” deprives gendered and subaltern bodies of essential nutrition and further upholds orthodox notions of purity and pollution, the very basis of the caste system.

    He also critiques how patriarchy manifests on the plate, especially when women, particularly aged mothers, are pressured by society to abandon their meat and fish consumption under the guise of religious devotion. This makes the consumption of strength-giving proteins an exclusive luxury for the male head of the household. Through an episode describing the cooking and eating of fish, he also highlights how patriarchy is mirrored within his community.

    During his student days at Osmania University, Ilaiah found himself torn between the traditional Marxist Left and the naxalite movement. Even as they claimed to fight feudalism, he found them both ideologically blind to caste. Moreover, their leadership was heavily monopolised by dominant-caste intellectuals, which is how varna and caste were consciously and subconsciously reproduced within the Left. According to Ilaiah, both movements used the labouring bodies of the Shudras merely for muscle power.

    Ilaiah’s teaching career exposed him to the soft violence of academic gatekeeping, which functioned as a kind of neo-agrahara in education. As a Shudra professor, he was constantly under scrutiny; recognising the limits of academic discourse, he aligned himself with grassroots civil rights bodies. As a result, his work argues that there can be no grammar of human rights without confronting the brutal reality of systemic caste. He also contends that major violations of human rights stem from collusion between state machinery and local dominant-caste landholders. Ilaiah’s lived experiences and reflections have allowed him to ground his academic and political concepts in the everyday survival strategies of marginalised communities.

    In a provocative inversion of Gandhian philosophy, Ilaiah argues that what the dominant nation state defines as “truth” is in fact a series of calculated “untruths”. From the Dalit-Bahujan standpoint, religious texts, historical chronicles, and nationalist myths are all deliberate fabrications that erase the history of production and labour. By deconstructing these untruths, he seeks to build an organic counter-hegemonic framework grounded in historical reality. Ilaiah believes that his work has won widespread acclaim on the global stage, securing his status as a pioneering political theorist. Yet, within India, he has faced, and continues to face, ostracisation from elite academic circles, along with a relentless barrage of criminal lawsuits, state-backed surveillance, and direct death threats.

    While Ilaiah makes a powerful case for a unified labouring identity, he tends to glide past the deep schisms within the modern Shudra category and the actual politics at play. Many dominant, landowning farming communities under the Shudra or OBC label are themselves direct perpetrators of economic exploitation and physical violence against Dalit labourers. In one of his early essays, Ilaiah introduced the categories of upper and lower Shudras and urged readers not to treat the Shudra as a monolithic category. Even so, without a direct critique of Shudra landlordism, any theory of a unified working collective remains incomplete.

    Today, the oppressed-caste youth are moving straight from agriculture into the digital gig economy. Driven by big data, apps, and hidden algorithms, this new digital proletariat requires a new critical vocabulary to track how old social hierarchies are reified and rewritten in software code. In the final pages, Ilaiah speaks directly to a younger generation of scholars trying to survive India’s hyper-competitive, corporate university system.

    At a time when public discourse faces aggressive political flattening, Ilaiah’s work remains an essential counter-history. For Ilaiah, true social liberation demands a radical return to the material realities of physical work. A Shudra Life reminds us that the right to think, write, and create theory is a basic human entitlement that belongs to every human being, irrespective of birth-imposed identities.

    Nikhil Sanjay-Rekha Adsule is a senior research scholar at IIT Delhi.

    GET OUR NEWSLETTERS

    Summary

    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd’s autobiography, “A Shudra Life,” offers an alternative political history, challenging conventional narratives from both the Right and the Left. The book highlights the intellectual contributions of agrarian working classes, particularly his Kuruma community, and critiques the gatekeeping of knowledge. Ilaiah’s work emphasizes the influence of women in his life, the significance of manual labor as political philosophy, and exposes contradictions in the Indian state regarding language, food, and caste. He advocates for a radical return to material realities for social liberation, despite facing ostracization and threats within India.

    Key Questions & Insights(AIⓘ)

    What is the central theme of Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd’s autobiography, “A Shudra Life”?

    How did the women in Ilaiah’s life influence his anti-caste feminist thinking?

    What is Ilaiah’s critique of the education system regarding manual labor?

    How does Ilaiah contrast the “white cow” with the “black buffalo” in his work?

    What is Ilaiah’s perspective on the role of English in challenging the caste system?

    How does Ilaiah critique patriarchy and hierarchies embedded in food cultures?

    What was Ilaiah’s criticism of the traditional Marxist Left and Naxalite movement?

    What challenges has Ilaiah faced within India despite his global acclaim?

    What is a key limitation in Ilaiah’s argument for a unified laboring identity?

  • Irony of FCRA regulation: Foreign funds in Christian orgs benefited elites the most

    If one calculates the Brahmins and Baniyas who benefited from free education and healthcare at Christian institutions, funded by Western donors for mission charity, they would outnumber all other castes.

    Written by : Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd

    Published:23rd Oct, 2026 at 4:53 PM

    The anti-Christian agenda of the RSS and BJP Government, by adopting various measures like the FCRA Bill, anti-conversion laws, and other forms of systemic attacks, is to ensure that the Dalit, Adivasi, and Shudra communities do not get education and global connectivity on par with the Brahmin, Bania, and other upper castes. 

    The RSS and BJP assessment is that earlier only the Brahmin, Bania and other upper caste youth benefited from Christian education and health institutions, though built and run with the help of foreign money. But now they have their own private English-medium educational institutions and private hospitals. Even in earlier regimes headed by the Congress, they only benefited from the best Christian education and health institutions. The Christian institutions also ignored the role of the caste system in denying SC/ST/OBCs access to their top institutions, as they did not adopt any caste-based reservation policy.  

    In the early modern period India did not have great non-Christian medical institutes like Christian Medical College and Hospital (CMCH, established in 1900) and St. Stephen’s College of Delhi, established in 1881. Even in the early days of Independence for best modern English-medium education and allopathic health treatment the upper castes depended on the Christian institutions.

    Delhi University was established only in 1922. The All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Delhi was established only in 1956. The rich upper castes depended on these world-class private Christian missionary institutions. They too were willing to serve them. Though they were collecting fees, it was never like the present upper caste owned private institutions. Even now there is a difference between the Christian and non-Christian fee structures in private education and health institutions. That was because they were/are subsidising the income from foreign donations through FCRA, and before FCRA was enacted, they were governed by the Indian tax laws. But the money was coming very much legally.

    However, for a long time, the Indian Christians—particularly Catholics—served the same upper castes who became anti-Christian now, not the poor lower castes. Only in the recent past did they diversify their educational and health services. For example, colleges like St. Stephens and CMC Vellore did not implement reservation for SC/ST/OBCs. They only gave some seats to privileged Christians.

    If only one could calculate the sheer number of Brahmins and Baniyas who studied in Christian institutions and got treatment in their hospitals, almost free of cost, they would outnumber any other caste persons. The point is that this was made possible because of foreign money coming to these institutions to subsidise education and health from Christian Western governments, churches, and individual families thinking that it is a mission charity to serve in a poor country like India. 

    The conversion question 

    Why are they saying only the poor get converted by force using FCRA-related money? The rich and privileged were also vulnerable to forced conversion in Christian schools, colleges, and hospitals. What would have happened if conversion were made a precondition to study in a Christian institution or get treated in our hospitals? 

    Though Islam existed in India for about a thousand years, the rulers had maintained great fraternal relations with the Brahmin, Bania and other savarna Hindus. Though Muslim rulers did not give them great education or health science, more upper castes got converted to Islam. They embraced the caste system and did nothing to reform the social conditions in India. During this period, neither the rulers nor the Islamic clergy established any institutions to serve the populations who have come to be listed as Dalits/OBCs/Adivasis.

    Without establishing any institutions that served outside the fold of their faith, the Hindu and Muslim ruling classes served only elites. Even as both collaborated to keep the caste system alive, they also created communal conflicts in competition with each other. As the ruling Hindus and Muslims played their deadly games, the food-producing Shudra/Dalit/Adivasis suffered illiteracy and poverty. In the latest stage of this ancient game, the RSS/BJP is preparing the ground for pushing the productive communities to primitive stages. Modern English education alone can help them to overcome their historical backwardness.

    Empowered SC/ST/OBCs threaten RSS/BJP

    Did Indian Christians create religious and communal conflict ever since Christianity became the source of Indian education and health science? Why this RSS/BJP animosity towards Indian Christianity? The main reason behind it is that over the last few decades, Christian institutions increasingly started educating the SC/ST/OBC communities too in their English-medium schools. 

    The fear is that if the Christian institutions are allowed to educate Dalit, Adivasi and Shudra youth with some amount of subsidised fees, they will fight against the caste system, monopoly exploitation, and compete in all spaces, including media. Using this draconian FCRA law, the poor Dalit, Adivasi, and Shudra forces could be controlled.

    As Abhijeet Dipke, Convenor of the Cockroach Janta Party, rightly said, these people are against the poor getting educated. In reality, RSS and BJP forces are against the Dalit, Adivasi, and Shudra (the poor) getting educated because they challenge the control of the Brahmin-Bania forces. They want to be more cautious after seeing Dipke’s own example of emerging as a leader of youth, being a Dalit himself. 

    Christianity as cultural buffer

    All the Christians in the world must know that before Christianity opened schools and hospitals, the majority productive communities—Shudras, Dalits, and Adivasis—were treated worse than cows. They worshipped cows but did not even touch the Dalits. 

    The first secular schools in the subcontinent were opened by Christian and colonial establishments where anybody could study irrespective of their caste, gender or religion. This stress on imparting mass education was a direct consequence of the period of enlightenment in Europe and impelled Christian missionaries to establish printing presses, scientific institutions, schools, colleges and hospitals. This secular Christian education helped Muslims and Brahmins to modernise themselves. Rajaramohan Roy and Sir Sayyad Hammed are outstanding examples of such modernisation. These institutions here and in England helped many freedom fighters to understand the world through the lens of secular democracy.  

    Until the British established the Department of Public Instruction in 1855 and opened the gates of mass education, Hindus and Muslims ran institutions that were exclusively for elites of their own communities in Urdu and in regional languages. The ancestors Shudra/Dalit/Adivasis were not allowed to read and write till the British, by all means, with a Christian communion arrived in India. Indeed, it is only with these radical changes that the first generation of educated social and political reformers emerged from our communities.

    Without caring for Brahminic values of human untouchability and the indignity of labour, they opened schools, though very few, for all Indians. Because of that, through the policy of education for all, a great couple, Jyothiba Phule and his wife, Savitribai, the first Shudras, got basic school education. They became the first slave liberators in the mid-19th century. This is the kind of secular educational path RSS is uncomfortable with. These kinds of changes are not acceptable in the Brahmanic tradition.

    Now the RSS and BJP want to close down all those educational institutions and health centres, like early hospitals, including the Christian Medical College Hospital, Vellore, over a period of time with a carefully crafted legal system.

    Through education and health, in fact, the Christian institutions helped more upper castes than the Dalit, Adivasi, and Shudra till recent years. Opening such public institutions for SC/ST/OBCs is slowly creating an awakening in them.

    The new FCRA laws do not affect the Muslim public institutions much because they do not have any significant educational or health institutions that were established with foreign money. Importantly, they rarely have secular institutions which provide services to all communities.

    These laws will not touch the Hindu institutions either. In any case, they mainly serve the upper castes by charging huge payments. There is no charity help in Ambani or Adani schools or in universities like Ashoka or any other such private universities. In Hindu private hospitals, there is no charity-based cheap treatment for the poor. But the Christian institutions did that earlier and continue to do so. This seems to be the RSS/BJP combine’s main concern, particularly in the education sector.

    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd is a Political Theorist, Social Activist and writer. His latest books are A Shudra Life – Autobiography and Harappa – God’s City of Civilisation. Views expressed are the author’s own.

  • This book highlights pivotal role of Shudras as builders of civilisation and productive communities

    https://googleads.g.doubleclick.net/pagead/ads?client=ca-pub-8162506735395902&output=html&h=440&adk=2723704725&adf=1790286646&pi=t.aa~a.4220607258~rp.1&abgtt=7&w=440&lmt=1792402394&rafmt=1&to=qs&pwprc=9806839777&format=440×440&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.counterview.net%2F2024%2F12%2Fthis-book-highlights-pivotal-role-of.html%3Fm%3D1&host=ca-host-pub-1556223355139109&fwr=1&pra=3&rpe=1&resp_fmts=3&sfro=1&aiof=14&asro=0&aimartd=4&aieuf=1&aicrs=1&fa=40&dt=1792410800258&bpp=1&bdt=111&idt=22&shv=r20261015&mjsv=m202610150101&ptt=9&saldr=aa&abxe=1&cookie=ID%3Df0a63d55ebbc8fd9%3AT%3D1792410794%3ART%3D1792410794%3AS%3DALNI_MaC-NqRF-gT_LSCeu56PTk_LIAuuA&gpic=UID%3D000015b6b20fb8b6%3AT%3D1792410794%3ART%3D1792410794%3AS%3DALNI_MY15toQr7S6jydn0pgl7Vc5NfrysA&eo_id_str=ID%3Df889b806cf0f599f%3AT%3D1792410794%3ART%3D1792410794%3AS%3DAA-AfjbaQFV3F7PXRkd7bVXhip_7&prev_fmts=0x0&nras=2&correlator=5154697462328&frm=20&pv=1&u_tz=330&u_his=1&u_h=896&u_w=414&u_ah=896&u_aw=414&u_cd=24&u_sd=3&adx=0&ady=299&biw=440&bih=762&scr_x=0&scr_y=0&eid=95405491%2C95405779%2C122881556%2C122881674%2C122881386&oid=2&pvsid=4930896620140900&tmod=1031254008&uas=1&nvt=2&fc=1920&brdim=0%2C0%2C0%2C0%2C414%2C0%2C440%2C762%2C440%2C762&vis=1&rsz=%7C%7Cs%7C&abl=NS&fu=128&bc=31&bz=1&pgls=CAA.&ifi=2&uci=a!2&fsb=1&dtd=23

    By Harsh Thakor

    The Shudra Rebellion, authored by Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd, presents a revolutionary perspective on Indian civilisation, shedding light on the overlooked contributions of Shudra nationalism. This work redefines the historical narrative by highlighting the pivotal role of Shudras as builders of civilisation and productive communities.

    At the heart of the book is the binary between the spade, symbolising labour, and the book, representing the Aryan textual tradition. Shepherd argues that while the Harappan civilisation was built on the collective labour of Shudras, Dalits, and Adivasis, Aryan culture glorified Brahminical texts and ritualism. The book critiques the Brahminical worldview that undermines the value of physical labour, portraying it as degrading, while exalting intellectual pursuits as superior.

    Shepherd goes beyond conventional academic boundaries to delve into the spiritual and cognitive dimensions of Shudra identity. He examines how the servility imposed on Shudras by the hierarchical Aryan system persisted across generations, stifling their potential for self-emancipation. Despite material progress, the Shudras remain spiritually and philosophically subjugated.

    https://googleads.g.doubleclick.net/pagead/ads?gdpr=0&client=ca-pub-8162506735395902&output=html&h=440&num_ads=1&adk=3933505106&adf=1607582810&pi=t.aa~a.2302334770~i.5~rp.4&abgtt=7&w=440&lmt=1792402394&rafmt=1&armr=3&sem=mc&pwprc=9806839777&ad_type=text_image&format=440×440&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.counterview.net%2F2024%2F12%2Fthis-book-highlights-pivotal-role-of.html%3Fm%3D1&host=ca-host-pub-1556223355139109&fwr=1&pra=3&rh=327&rw=392&rpe=1&resp_fmts=3&sfro=1&aiof=14&asro=0&aimartd=4&aieuf=1&aicrs=1&fa=27&dt=1792410800683&bpp=1&bdt=536&idt=-M&shv=r20261015&mjsv=m202610150101&ptt=9&saldr=aa&abxe=1&cookie=ID%3Df0a63d55ebbc8fd9%3AT%3D1792410794%3ART%3D1792410794%3AS%3DALNI_MaC-NqRF-gT_LSCeu56PTk_LIAuuA&gpic=UID%3D000015b6b20fb8b6%3AT%3D1792410794%3ART%3D1792410794%3AS%3DALNI_MY15toQr7S6jydn0pgl7Vc5NfrysA&eo_id_str=ID%3Df889b806cf0f599f%3AT%3D1792410794%3ART%3D1792410794%3AS%3DAA-AfjbaQFV3F7PXRkd7bVXhip_7&prev_fmts=0x0%2C440x440%2C440x134&nras=4&correlator=5154697462328&frm=20&pv=1&u_tz=330&u_his=1&u_h=896&u_w=414&u_ah=896&u_aw=414&u_cd=24&u_sd=3&adx=0&ady=1660&biw=440&bih=762&scr_x=0&scr_y=0&eid=95405491%2C95405779%2C122881556%2C122881674%2C122881386&oid=2&psts=AOrYGsmUbQGfQZ6Vo0U4JLB2ZDj7wuze4MQ8BJmah5ghIp4zlrFuIshHeUgp9uKiLesrTaUGHZpJJUH-JU6o90WNNnkPk-WJYGpFVHU&pvsid=4930896620140900&tmod=1031254008&uas=1&nvt=2&fc=1408&brdim=0%2C0%2C0%2C0%2C414%2C0%2C440%2C762%2C440%2C762&vis=1&rsz=%7C%7Cs%7C&abl=NS&fu=128&bc=31&bz=1&pgls=CAA.&ifi=4&uci=a!4&btvi=2&fsb=1&dtd=256

    The author constructs an alternative historical narrative, challenging the dominant academic discourse shaped by ‘Dwija’ intellectuals. Drawing on recent scientific works like those of Tony Joseph, Shepherd asserts that Shudras were the original founders of Indian civilisation. However, they were systematically marginalised by Brahminical agents who demeaned their “spade civilisation.”

    The book reproduces significant historical references, such as the letters of Chhatrapati Shahu Maharaj, a pioneer in promoting education and reservation for backward classes, and the writings of Jyotirao Phule, who fiercely critiqued Brahminical dominance.

    Shepherd explores the imposition of Hindi and the cultural hegemony of Sanskrit, linking these to the suppression of Shudra identity. He critiques how language politics has shaped public discourse and self-rule, drawing attention to the socio-political implications of English, local languages, and Sanskritic traditions.

    The book critiques Hindutva for erasing Shudra contributions from history and perpetuating Brahminical dominance. It also exposes the failure of left-liberal intellectuals to address caste in their anti-Hindutva discourse, highlighting their neglect of the systemic inequalities rooted in caste.

    Shepherd warns of the dangers posed to Shudras by the rise of Hindutva. He examines how constitutional democracy failed to address caste inequalities and how the RSS-BJP alliance resurrected Varnadharma ideology. The chapter on Vallabhbhai Patel critiques his inability to challenge caste hegemony within Gandhi’s vision of Hindu nationalism.

    https://googleads.g.doubleclick.net/pagead/ads?gdpr=0&client=ca-pub-8162506735395902&output=html&h=440&num_ads=1&adk=3933505106&adf=1977013506&pi=t.aa~a.2302334770~i.10~rp.4&abgtt=7&w=440&lmt=1792402394&rafmt=1&armr=3&sem=mc&pwprc=9806839777&ad_type=text_image&format=440×440&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.counterview.net%2F2024%2F12%2Fthis-book-highlights-pivotal-role-of.html%3Fm%3D1&host=ca-host-pub-1556223355139109&fwr=1&pra=3&rh=327&rw=392&rpe=1&resp_fmts=3&sfro=1&aiof=14&asro=0&aimartd=4&aieuf=1&aicrs=1&fa=27&dt=1792410800683&bpp=1&bdt=536&idt=-M&shv=r20261015&mjsv=m202610150101&ptt=9&saldr=aa&abxe=1&cookie=ID%3Df0a63d55ebbc8fd9%3AT%3D1792410794%3ART%3D1792410794%3AS%3DALNI_MaC-NqRF-gT_LSCeu56PTk_LIAuuA&gpic=UID%3D000015b6b20fb8b6%3AT%3D1792410794%3ART%3D1792410794%3AS%3DALNI_MY15toQr7S6jydn0pgl7Vc5NfrysA&eo_id_str=ID%3Df889b806cf0f599f%3AT%3D1792410794%3ART%3D1792410794%3AS%3DAA-AfjbaQFV3F7PXRkd7bVXhip_7&prev_fmts=0x0%2C440x440%2C440x134%2C440x440&nras=5&correlator=5154697462328&frm=20&pv=1&u_tz=330&u_his=1&u_h=896&u_w=414&u_ah=896&u_aw=414&u_cd=24&u_sd=3&adx=0&ady=2912&biw=440&bih=762&scr_x=0&scr_y=0&eid=95405491%2C95405779%2C122881556%2C122881674%2C122881386&oid=2&psts=AOrYGsmUbQGfQZ6Vo0U4JLB2ZDj7wuze4MQ8BJmah5ghIp4zlrFuIshHeUgp9uKiLesrTaUGHZpJJUH-JU6o90WNNnkPk-WJYGpFVHU&pvsid=4930896620140900&tmod=1031254008&uas=1&nvt=2&fc=1408&brdim=0%2C0%2C0%2C0%2C414%2C0%2C440%2C762%2C440%2C762&vis=1&rsz=%7C%7Cs%7C&abl=NS&fu=128&bc=31&bz=1&pgls=CAA.&ifi=5&uci=a!5&btvi=3&fsb=1&dtd=256

    The book explores the integral role of Shudras in agriculture and their suppression by Brahminical forces, which stifled progress and experimentation. Shepherd argues that the spiritual system of Vedic texts pushed Indian civilisation backward, creating a historical disaster.

    The chapter ‘Hindi for Shudras, Sanskrit for Devatas’ highlights how the imposition of Hindi suppressed Shudras, while Sanskrit remained a tool of Brahminical domination. Shepherd critiques the Hindutva agenda of promoting globalisation and privatisation in education, further marginalising rural and economically disadvantaged communities.

    While the book is a treasure trove of insights, it has its limitations. Shepherd’s analysis is heavily caste-centric, often overlooking the broader socio-economic and class dynamics. By focusing solely on caste, the author sidelines the achievements and complexities of Indian civilisation and its economic history.

    The Shudra Rebellion is an essential read for anyone seeking to understand the suppressed histories of Indian civilisation. It raises important questions and challenges the reader to rethink established narratives.

  • Centuries Of Brahminical Hegemony: Kancha’s “The Shudras” Explains The Problem

    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd

    On the celebration of the birth anniversary of Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar and in the context of Shudras revolution in nations building, the Centre for Human Dignity and Development (CCHD), IMPRI Impact and Policy Research Institute, New Delhi organized on April 29, 2021, a Book Discussion on “The Shudras Vision For a New Path“.

    The eminent panelists include Prof Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd, Indian Political Theorist, Prolific Writer, Dalit Rights Activist, and Dr. Arvind Kumar, Assistant Professor, Centre for the Study of Social Exclusion and Inclusive Policy (CSSIP), Jamia Milia Islamia (JMI), New Delhi as the speakers. Prof Sukhadeo Thorat, Eminent Economist; Professor Emeritus, Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU); Chairperson, Indian Institute of Dalit Studies (IIDS) as the chair of the talk. Dr. Ajay Gudavarthy, Associate Professor, Center for Political Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU), New Delhi and Dr. Aakash Singh Rathore, Series Editor, Rethinking India, Penguin/Vintage; Professor of Politics, Philosophy, and Law, LUISS University, Rome as the discussants of the talk.

    Setting the tone for the book discussion, the speaker, Prof Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd, very briefly touched upon the caste politics of our country and gave an idea of his book. Prof Ilaiah shared very profoundly why he chose “Shudras” as the title of his book.  In this context, he discussed how certain forces in our country are always coming forward to control the marginalized classes by their political power.

    Upper Caste Exploitation And Discrimination

    He also emphasized that since the Vedic or ancient period, the upper castes have been dominating and exploiting the lower classes especially in the context of Shudras who are mainly considered as a working and production-based class in the Varna system in Hinduism, whereas the three upper classes – Brahmin, Kshatriya & Vaishya always have behaved as the master of the Shudras. The Brahmin class is always recognized for economic-social development construction, civilizational building, and intellectual legitimacy.Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd at Kerala Literature Festival, 2018.

    Prof Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd gave the economic definition of the present Shudras in Indian society. He criticized Brahmanism in many aspects and asserted that why the Shudras did not allow wearing the sacred thread “Janeu”, why did they not play the role of priest yet and why did the Shudras not get access to the power language (Sanskrit in Ancient India and English in Present India). He presented a form of linguistic formation, which also came as a barrier in the Shudras’ academic learning.

    In discussion, Prof Ilaiah expressed his concern regarding the hegemonic characteristic of BJP, RSS, and other political forces, and how they all are suppressing the Shudras in every sphere of life in Indian society.  He also said that it is ironic of our Indian society that till today no text has been written on the Shudras philosophy and how the Shudras became the only muscle power and vote bank for the right-wing party.

    It is seen that there is no representation of the Shudras in the central government to date, only two Prime Ministers were elected from this community but only for a short period. In addition, it is also a well-known fact that in our country there is no representation of this class among the 100 industrialists and 25 monopolists. No doubt the Shudras hold 52% of the population of our country and without them the BJP, RSS cannot remain in power, but still, their concerns are not addressed very well at the national level. The Shudras are still facing the hit of Vedic deployment in the name of secularism and anti-colonialism.

    Further Prof Ilaiah talked about how the Adivasis, on one hand, got recognition because of their separate location. On the other hand, the Shudras always face discrimination from the economic, political, and spiritual hegemonic groups. They were always recognized as non-intellectual, non- modernists and considered as the slave of the Brahmin priest. He said that this book also suggests how the English language is now considered property in Indian society. He criticized how caste politics also decides the leadership of our country. He gave an example of our present Prime Minister and his “baniya” economic support in his win.

    Where The Book Stands

    In short, Prof Ilaiah says about his book’s motive which trends a path for Shudras friendly relation establishment. He also expressed his concerns and said that the RSS brought a new form of Brahmanical functional groups in the present Indian society, which also presented a different Hindu centric approach in the form of hegemonic services of the temple, wealth, political and medicinal values (in the name of cow urine). He also expressed his concern in the context of the lack of Shudras literature; he praised the “Gulamgiri” which is the best creation in this field to date.  He also appreciated his young team members who all belong to the Shudras community itself and did not conceal their identity.

    The discussant of this discussion, Prof Aakash Singh Rathore, begins by saying that this book is the fifth part of the series and also gave a brief idea of the previous series of books. Further, he applauded this book and said that it is quite relevant in the present era of caste politics. This book suggests a normative platform of how to rethink our realities and imagine the political and public spheres that are very constrained now.

    He emphasized that this book also gives some suggestions in the context of a new, equitable, and prosperous future for the intellectual and policymakers of modern India. This book also advocates the ideological revolution and constitutional values in nation-building and presents a new vision to rethink India in the context of the principle of graded inequality. At last, he suggested that finally, it’s time to spin the wheels to get rid of the spiritual, social, political, and economic slavery of hegemonic Brahmins and build an equitable and just nation for all.

    The next discussant, Dr. Ajay Gudavarthy, came up with his strong comments on this book and considered it a very timely book. According to him, this book presents the conceptual basis of a vision of Hindu politics and Hindu Rashtra in present India. In other words, it presents an epistemic philosophy and dominant hegemony in the context of the marginalized class.  This book has also identified a sociological conflict that we lost in the history of Buddhism. It is a well-known fact that Buddhism was the first revolution against Brahmanism in the dimension of social, political, and economic dominance in ancient India. He also raised some questions regarding the Shudras, why this class is always considered only for productive works in Indian society.

    Further, Dr. Gudavarthy asserted that on the one hand Shudras talk about mobility and ideational work, but on the other hand, they present self-concealing contributions. For example, at the recent farmers’ protest, there was the representation of OBC only.  In this sense, why did they not come up with their concerns, as it is known that the Shudras are agrarian or productive class? He presented that there is an indirect contradiction between Shudras and OBC, because of the ignorance of history. So, it is time to address this issue. He also drew attention to the myth and mythologies of caste philosophy, which is the main reason why the Shudras did not get real recognition in Indian Society.

    Dr. Gudavarthy talked about the introduction part of the book which does not explain clearly in the context of upliftment of the Shudras, it only discusses the historical hegemony of the right-wing, culture logic of late capitalism, and power egalitarian things. At last, he said that this book presents symbolic appropriation which is the cause of continuous games of inclusion and exclusion in society.  Therefore, this is a need of the hour to bring about the kind of equivalence and resolve the dynamic of powers in the present social theory.

    The next speaker, Dr. Arvind Kumar, started his discussion with some policy concerns related to the backlog seats of the reserved category and also shared his personal experiences on the same. Dr. Kumar profoundly shared how the Shudras have faced denial and injustice since the historical period in Indian society, as they did not have the right to read and write, they were only considered as the minions of Brahmins in that period. While discussing the title of this book, he said that in our country we can see a clear politics of naming, that’s why we intentionally chose the word “Shudras” in the title, so we can address this class and its ground reality in true sense.

    Representation, Methodology, And Policy

    In addition, his concern was regarding the question in terms of methodology in the context of the academic literature of the backward class and depressed class. In his final note, he raised the issue of how Shudra lost, just because of the foray of social injustice by the upper class. Finally, in this sense, there should be the presentation of egalitarian empirical work.

    Further, Prof Sukhadeo Thorat gave his remarks over the entire discussion. He agrees that no doubt there are various problems and issues of OBC and Shudras, but it is not yet raised properly, that’s why this problem remains. Why there is a need for three categorizations- economic, political, and ideological of Shudras in the context of definition? Why are we not considering the NSSO data to acquire true information about the socio-economic status of the Shudras and OBC? He suggested to young scholars to follow the data in their research work, to give validation/ authentication of the arguments.

    He also addressed the Shudras as the cultivators of land with their history, as they didn’t get any high yielding or developed technology but they only carried or followed their traditions through the experiences. That’s why they faced other occupation and education restrictions in that period, which also brought the practices of untouchability in ancient India.

    According to Manusmriti, cultivation was considered an inferior profession, that’s why Shudras were treated badly as they were wage laborers. But today the Shudras are also producers and owners of the land. No doubt graded equality also misinterpreted the problems of the Shudras. In this sense, it is needed to represent the issues of this class logically.

    Prof Sukhadeo Thorat also talked clearly about the representation of the Shudras in Indian politics. He emphasized that the OBC & Shudras are majority class although they are not in power. As they hold 52% of the total population in the country, in this sense we cannot always blame the upper caste. Finally, he suggested that we should think critically about where Shudras are lacking in the contemporary world based on ideology and social education.

    Then the discussion moved once again to the speaker Prof Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd and he confronted the idea of Prof Sukhadeo Thorat in many aspects and asserted that land is not the symbol of richness, knowledge should be considered as richness. He also disagreed on how we address the questions of historical and philosophical issues based on numbers.

    Mr. Manikant also contributed to this book discussion and shared that we have to identify those areas where the OBC & Shudras are failing. He also emphasized that there is an urgent need for Shudras consciousness in the new normative direction of understanding the essence of Brahmin’s modernity. In the final concluding view of Prof Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd, this volume is only the beginning in the name of Shudras’ revolution, and the main objective of this book is to start the conversation on the same.

    Acknowledgment: Priyanka Walter is a Research Intern at IMPRI and is currently pursuing MA (PPG) Course from Chinmaya Vishwavidyapeeth, Kochi, Kerala.

  • Why and how I wrote the novel ‘Harappa: God’s City of Civilisation’

    Neither Ayodhya named in the Ramayana nor Dwaraka named in the Mahabharata have proven excavational evidence of having been ancient cities. My novel, on the other hand, draws on the world’s oldest city – Harappa – that existed around 3000 BCE in the Sindhu river basin, as proven by excavations and DNA studies, writes Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd

    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd October 15, 2026

    My just-released novel Harappa: God’s City of Civilisation, published by Unbound Script, New Delhi, with magnificent illustrations by Priti Gulati Cox is an unusual experiment in the literary history of India. Critic Satya Sagar described it as a counter myth and product of courageous imagination. We have in the guise of history only purely mythical Brahminic Sanskrit literature, texts starting with Rigveda followed by Ramayana, Mahabharataand so on. There is no historical source of production, animal economy and collective culture and even what they call civilization. Ramayana and Mahabharata were woven around characters of Brahmin and Kshatriya heroes, ascetics and some women.

    My novel, on the other hand, draws on the world’s oldest city – Harappa – that existed around 3000 BCE in the Sindhu river basin. Excavations, DNA studies, reading and rereading of archaeological artefacts by scholars from India and abroad have proved that there was a city with this name and it had a civilizational, cultural and economic strength that was unmatched globally at the time.

    India as a nation today can be proud of its civilizational roots in Harappa. The protagonist of my novel is Harappa as the one who builds the world’s greatest city of his time, with the assistance of his wife Maisamma after Harappa himself domesticates the buffalo. Maisamma builds the world’s first water tank. They gradually transform Jambhu Dwipa, a village named after Harappa’s father into a massive city Harappa. He becomes the first king of that city state. The story goes on till some foreigners arrive.

    Harappa was the ancient historical city, not Ayodhya

    Harappa was the first major global city. In many aspects it was different from the ancient cities of Egypt, Israel, Greece and Rome. Harappa had many special civilizational strengths that other ancient cities did not. From houses built with bricks and sustainable wood to canals, the connection with the present Indian village and town with agrarian life is apparent.

    Harappa laid the foundation for the advancement of knowledge of humans and has left behind information about their living environment, animal economy, productivity, science, engineering almost 1500 years before Aryan (Brahmin, Kshatriya and Bania) migration or invasion took place. It was much later that the rest of the world reached that level of civilizational advancement.

    In contrast, the town we know of as Ayodhya, the capital of Dasharatha, the father of Rama – now what the Hindutvawadis call Rama Rajya – seems to be a city of much later period. It seems that most of the so-called ancient cities and other locations that bear names from the texts of Ramayanaor Mahabharata were named after those names first appeared in those texts. Harappa, on the other hand, is the oldest historical name of a place. I am of the opinion that the city could have been named after its builder, Harappa. The practice of naming villages and cities after people has been a historical practice in India. My belief has been reinforced by the fact that there are hundreds of such names that end with the suffix “appa” in South India. Harappan troops who migrated to the south may have taken these names with them.

    Ayodhya and Dwaraka

    Neither Ayodhya named in the Ramayana nor Dwaraka named in the Mahabharata have proven excavational evidence of having been ancient cities. Some excavations were done in Ayodhya after a court order in the context of the Babri Masjid dispute and a report was prepared by the Archaeological Survey of India saying that there are some relics of ancient constructions in that place dating to 700-300 BCE. However, it did not have strong evidence in terms of artefacts. Not much evidence was found about Ayodhya’s economy, animals, technology and so on. Even if we go by that report, Ayodhya came into existence much later than Harappa. Obviously it was built almost 800 to 1000 years after the Aryan Brahmin migration took place. There has not been a single scholarly study on those findings from the Ayodhya excavation unlike in the case of Harappa. The descriptions of the characters, their dress codes, the palaces they lived in, the ornaments they used and the chariots they rode in Ramayana give the impression that they were very modern. How did those kings and their women get such clothes and ornaments? If that was an ancient civilizational life, how could they use such dresses, ornaments, houses and vehicles? Of course, their idea of Krita Yuga is very recent and imaginary with absolutely no evidence. Both Ramayana and Mahabharata are novels written with purely imagined figures. The Indian Shudra/Dalit/Adivasis should not trust any book written by Brahmin/Ksatriya/Vaisya writers because they wrote only about themselves. They never even recognized the existence of the productive forces of India – Shudra/Dalit/Adivasis – let alone their antecedence. This is where my novel Harappa becomes very important for the future generations of India. Even the Brahmin Brahmin/Bania/Ksatriya youth have to realize that the Sanskrit literature, which did not deal with the lives and contribution of productive masses, has no value for the nation. The Indian youth have to reconstruct the Indian past from the Harappa city civilization onwards to acquire a respectable stature in the global knowledge systems. Reading mere Brahmin/Ksatriya life as ancient parampara of the nation will lead to a clash of cultures among Indian castes. Unity among all castes becomes possible only when you go to the casteless society of Harappan times.

    The true story of an ancient civilization and its people lies in Harappa, not in Ayodhya or Dwaraka.An illustration in ‘Harappa’ by Priti Gulati Cox; and an illustration of Ram’s return to Ayodhya by Balasaheb Pant Pratinidhi in Ramchandra Madhwa Mahishi’s ‘Chitra Ramayana’ (1916) [Source: Wikipedia)

    My novel

    Harappa: God’s City of Civilisationshows the evolutionary process of human society, economy, relations between humans and animals, technology and science in India’s antiquity. The book Ramayana, on the other hand, does not show the kind of animal economy the Ayodhya kingdom had starting with the rule of Dasharatha. Even a work of fiction will have to show the nature of agriculture, animals, artisan production and usage of technology in those times. The Ramayana only deals with the Ksatriya royalty and Brahmin ascetics. How did society survive without food producers at that time? Who were producing food, supplying meat and milk products to Ksatriya rulers and Brahmin ascetics? Naturally when there were Ksatriya kings and Brahmin ascetics, there would have been Shudra food producers, based on the varna-based division. In that social system, Ksatriya kings and Brahmin ascetics never got involved in food production. A story of ancient India would have to show ancient values, lifestyles, artefacts, technology. If a narrative claims to be ancient, yet features lifestyles and technologies that are more recent, the writer’s maturity will be called to question. Even a novel has to be located within a time frame. If Ramayana was written by a person called Valmiki the text has to give an indication of the time frame in which lived and the social, economic, cultural environment that existed in those times. The Ramayana does not tell us anything about the lives of the people who sustained that society. My novel tells about the masses who built this nation’s early civilization from which India of today evolved. 

    Harappa shows the ancient evolutionary character of society that was learning things gradually and collectively. The production process is a collective labour process. So is war. The Ramayana tells about how Vanaras helped Rama in the war against Ravana. That was a collective effort. In fact food production, house construction, making productive tools and weapons for war need a more organized long-term collective effort. The Ramayanadoes not tell anything about that fundamental process in Ayodhya or the life in nearby villages.

    Any spiritual or social text will have to deal with masses of that time. They may be slaves or masters. But Ramayana and Mahabharata dealt only with the Ksatriyas and Brahmins who constituted the ruling class and the religious heads. Such books do not reflect India and the Indian people. When Ksatriya rulers are projected as gods and goddesses the very idea of religion itself gets distorted. Once the idea of God is caste-centred, that divine agency remains completely alienated from the productive masses on whom humanity depends for survival. My novel runs contrary to the narrative in the Ramayana and Mahabharata and is set hundreds of years before even their fictional time frame of Krita Yuga and Dwapara Yuga.  

    Domestication of animals and birds

    So far no social science book or a work of fiction has dealt with the process of how human beings could domesticate sheep, goats and more importantly one of the most ferocious wild animals, the water buffalo. Nobody has given an account even of when and how the chicken was domesticated. Domestication of animals and birds was a scientific process and involved studying the psychology of animals and birds. My novel deals with this struggle of Harappa, his father Jambhav and his mother Sindh to domesticate the buffalo, sheep, goat and chicken. While Jambhav domesticated sheep and goat, Harappa himself domesticated buffalo. His mother’s efforts to domesticate chicken and how she laid the foundations of the milk and curd (yogurt) economy has been graphically explained. Generally, writers presume that these animals were around to be used by humans. But before they were domesticated humans had to hunt and eat. After animal domestication, human lifestyle underwent a sea change as the meat and milk economy became the home and village economy. Without the domestication of animals and birds, humans could not have sedentary village economies and without such economies no city could have come into existence. Harappa: God’s City of Civilisation is a creative depiction of this process. ‘Harappa: God’s City of Civilisation’, by Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd; Unbound Script, Delhi; Hardcover, 80 pages, Rs 399

    How I realized that Harappa was a man’s name

    Most villages and cities in India even today are named after the man or woman who played a key role in settling that village or city. It is a known fact that cities and towns are the result of expansion of villages. In ancient and medieval times, cities were never planned and built like Chandigarh in modern India. Nowhere in the world were cities a one-time building project. A city is formed by the continuous expansion of a village.

    There are a number of names in South India that end with “appa”. There are also godheads like Ayyappa, Beerappa, Ramappa and so on. The Ayyappa temple of Kerala is well known. Beerappa is the god of the shepherd communities across South India, more pronouncedly in Maharashtra among the Dhangar community and among the Kuruma/Kuruba communities in Telangana, Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka. A Beerappa temple can be seen in every village where these caste communities live. The Ramappa temple is located in north Telangana, near the town of Mulugu.

    There are hundreds of personal and family names suffixed with “appa” in South India – Bangarappa, Veerappa, Mallappa and so on, apart from those are named after deities like Ayyappa, Beerappa and Ramappa. There are several villages with names that end with the word “Appa”. It is this socio-anthropological cultural environment of South India that got me thinking that Harappa would have been the name of a man in ancient India, after whom the historical city was named.

    The process of writing this novel began with a sociological understanding of this similarity in names as well as the discovery by archaeologists and historians that Harappa shared many similarities with South India – people’s skin colour, their agricultural tools, housing patterns and so on.

    The name Harappa does not figure in any Aryan Sanskrit books or names of people of Aryan heritage even today.

    A village settles and advances only when there is a well developed animal economy, agriculture and artisanal craftsmanship. The people can develop all kinds of tools in the village only when there is a reliable supply of food available and they don’t have to hunt and fish everyday for survival.

    In my novel the village Jambhu Dwipa comes into existence with the domestication of sheep, goat, chicken, dog by Harappa’s father Jambhav and mother Sindh. Jambhav’s father and mother were Mahisha and Pocha. Mahisha and Pocha were the first known couple who lived depending on nature and under trees and caves, but from Jambhav and Sindh onwards animal and chicken domestication paved the way for artisanship and the settling of a village. That was great advancement.

    The idea of God

    The idea of God has been presented in the book as a process of new thinking and imagination. The people of Jumbhu Dwipa were also forming new ideas about life.

    The idea of God was abstract at the beginning. Then some people wanted to introduce idol worship. However, Harappa strongly opposes the idea of projecting humans as gods and goddesses. But in the process, Harappa becomes the king of the city state. Then another person, Adidevudu, claims that he has some speculative, foreseeing powers and predicts aliens arriving and destroying his city state. Harappa begins to take him seriously. Adidevudu thus became the first human being to be accepted as equivalent to God.

    My view is that those indigenous (Mulavasi) people of India, by the time they built the city of Harappa and that great civilization, had a well developed idea of God in two contending forms – abstract God and human God. Over a period of time the idea of human God took the form of an idol. Adidevudu represents that divine cultural stream.

    This novel is in fact going to establish that mythological books like Ramayanaand Mahabharata were written to bring society under the complete control of Brahmin writers and priests with the assistance of Ksatriya rulers. Both these castes became anti-production and gradually turned against productive science, technology and advancement. Those adults and children who read Harappa: God’s City of Civilisation will realize that India’s ancient roots lie in Harappa.


    Forward Press also publishes books on Bahujan issues. Forward Press Books sheds light on the widespread problems as well as the finer aspects of Bahujan (Dalit, OBC, Adivasi, Nomadic, Pasmanda) society, culture, literature and politics. Contact us for a list of FP Books’ titles and to order. Mobile: +917827427311, Email: info@forwardmagazine.in

    About The Author

    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd

    Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd is a political theorist, author and activist. He has been a professor of Political Science at Osmania University, Hyderabad and director of the Centre for the Study of Social Exclusion and Inclusive Policy at Maulana Azad National Urdu University, Hyderabad. He is the author of ‘Why I Am Not a Hindu’, ‘Buffalo Nationalism’ and ‘Post-Hindu India’ 

  • Unveiling of the Statue of Prof. Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd

    On the auspicious occasion of the celebration of 209 years of Indian English

    PACPET, Hyderabad | 4 October 2026

  • 209th Indian English Day & Prof. Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd

  • Why We Need Savitribai Phule’s India: Sujana

    Yadav’s Bold Speech on Equality

    In this powerful and thought-provoking speech, Sujana Yadav (Founding & Core Committee Member of the Telangana People’s Front) discusses the critical role of English education in empowering women and marginalized communities in India. She challenges the current education system, calls out the imposition of majoritarian ideologies, and emphasizes the need to look up to icons like Savitribai Phule and Dr. B.R.

    Ambedkar. Yadav passionately advocates for the establishment of high-quality, international-standard “Telangana Public Schools” to ensure equal rights and constitutional morality for all.